After spending two years in Australia, I knew there was one very important thing I needed to do when I arrived in New Zealand: try the pies.
If you’ve spent any time in Australia or New Zealand, you’ll know there’s a bit of a rivalry over who makes the better pie. Naturally, I needed to do a taste test for myself in order to make an educated decision.
And I’m sorry Aus, but you don’t even come close.
And if you’re thinking I’m talking about the pies your mom makes for Thanksgiving, you’ve got it all wrong.
What Exactly Is a Pie?
A pie, at least in this part of the world, is a beautiful thing.
We’re talking about a handheld savoury pie, wrapped in golden flaky pastry (at least the good ones are), and filled with slow-cooked godliness.

Think mince (ground beef), chunky steak, chicken, or a combination of meat, cheese and other delicious fillings. They’re usually served piping hot, eaten straight out of your hands, and perfect for breakfast, lunch or a cheeky afternoon snack.

After travelling all over the country and getting through a questionable number of pies, I’d say I’ve earned the right to call myself somewhat of an expert. So, if you’re looking for the best spots to grab a pie in New Zealand, you’ve come to the right place.
Here are my top 10 from around the country:
North island
1. Lunchbar Eighty8 – Hamilton
Now, Hamilton isn’t going to make everyone’s New Zealand itinerary, especially if you’re only here for a limited amount of time. But if you happen to be driving through, this is a mandatory stop.
I worked in Hamilton for about three months, and I found it pretty hard not to stop here on my way to work every morning.
Lunchbar Eighty8 looks like a little hole-in-the-wall takeaway shop, but don’t let appearances fool you. They have just about every pie you could imagine, from paua (abalone) to a $20 lobster pie.
If you do end up making a stop here, I have three recommendations:
- Chicken Cranberry
- Caramelised pork
- Mince double cheese
2. Patricks Pies – Rotorua
You can tell as soon as you walk in that these guys know what they’re doing. There are awards covering the walls and an almost overwhelming number of pies to choose from.
The prices were very reasonable, and the pies were absolutely massive. Honestly, they weighed what felt like a kilo each
Their mince and cheese has picked up plenty of awards, and for good reason. You really can’t go wrong with it. But if you’re feeling a little more adventurous, I’d recommend trying the roasted duck & mushroom.
3. Puku Pies & Kai Lyall Bay – Wellington
There are a few Puku Pies locations around Wellington, so when you come across one, make sure to pop in.
They have about ten pies on their menu which makes choosing a little less overwhelming. But if you’re still struggling to decide, I’d recommend the jalapeno beef brisket or the mince and double beer cheese pie.
Both were absolutely loaded with filling, and the cheese was practically everywhere. Make sure you grab some napkins because these pies are messy in the best way possible.
South Island
4. Picton Village Bakery – Picton
Straight off the ferry from the North Island, we were starving. We stumbled across this little bakery, and it hit the spot.
They have an “Out of the Ordinary” section which contained a Sweet Chili Chicken and cream cheese and let me tell you, I was not disappointed.
A great little stop to refuel after crossing the Cook Strait!
5. The Butcher’s Pie Shop – Christchurch

Located in the heart of Christchurch’s CBD, Butcher’s is a great stop if you’re exploring the city. If you’re heading to the Riverside market, swing by and grab yourself a Pork Belly & Apple pie or their six-hour-hour braised beef. Both are incredible options and a good excuse to take a break from sightseeing.
6. Prebbleton Bakehouse – Prebbleton, Christchurch
Just outside of Christchurch you’ll find a bakery that has locals lining up out the door. After eating a crazy amount of pies during my time in New Zealand, I eventually developed a go-to-order: chicken cranberry and camembert. And Prebbleton’s version was without a doubt, my favourite. The combination of creamy camembert and sweet cranberry was absolutely to die for. This one I’d happily drive out of my way for.
7. Sheffield Pies – Sheffield
On your way out to Arthur’s Pass, this is a mandatory stop.
Out of all the pies I’ve had in New Zealand, this one takes the cake. They have a mouth-watering Venison and Whiskey pie that, if they haven’t sold out by the time you arrive, is an absolute must-try. I loved it so much I went back and ordered a second one. #noregrets

8. PJ’s Pies – Hanmer Springs
In New Zealand you’ll find plenty of pies sold from petrol stations and supermarkets. PJ’s pies is one of the more well-known pie brands, but in Hanmer Springs, you’ll find a cute little shop that sells some of their interesting flavours.
They have NZ’s famous crayfish pie, which will set you back $50. You’ll need to get there early, though, as they tend to sell out fast.
If spending $50 on a pie isn’t quite in your budget (understandable) then I highly recommend their Steak and Blue Cheese pie instead.
9. Milford Road Merchant – Te Anau
This one was a cute little shop that I did not expect to have such good pies.
At around $13 each, these were probably some of the most expensive pies I had in New Zealand, where the average pie cost around $6-$9. I’d consider them more of a special treat than an everyday lunch. They had a cheeseburger pie and a Chinese 5 spiced meat pie. Both of them were incredible and I’d never tasted anything quite like them before.
Not a Pie, But worth the Mention
10. Miga Hako – Dunedin
Okay, so this isn’t a pie shop or even a bakery, but I couldn’t leave it off the list because it deserves a shout-out.
This place serves rice balls and it is just as beautiful as a pie.

Now, a rice ball is exactly what it sounds like: a giant ball of rice. But on the inside you’ll find crispy chicken, avocado and extra sauce. It is a heavyweight food sensation.
We first discovered it while walking through Dunedin’s CBD after spotting a sign advertising rice balls for just $4.50. Naturally, we had to go investigate.
Apparently, rice balls became popular in Christchurch thanks to places like Sushi Ball House. You can even find rice balls that weigh up to 2kg.
If you’re looking for a cheap, filling lunch you’ll definitely want to give one a try.
From classic mince and cheese to some pretty questionable combinations, New Zealand has absolutely nailed the art of the humble pie. And if I have learned anything it is never underestimate a small local bakery. Some of the best pies I’ve had were in places I probably wouldn’t have stopped otherwise. So, if you’re traveling around New Zealand, do yourself a favour and skip the usual sandwich for lunch. Find a bakery, grab a pie and see what all the fuss is about.
-D



